Tuesday, May 26, 2020
Home Opinions BR Ambedkar burning Manusmriti - why the act was flawed

BR Ambedkar burning Manusmriti – why the act was flawed

Also Read

Dr Ambedkar gave two big jolts to the 20th century caste-Hindu society. One was leading the mass conversion of his Mahar people to Buddhism in 1956 and the earlier one, in 1927 when he was still Hindu, was the burning of the Manu Smriti.

It started with a peaceful Satyagraha in Mahad in coastal Maharashtra, where the untouchables were denied access to water from a tank. Upper castes filed multiple court cases arguing that the tank was private property and could be restricted. Ambedkar seems to have lost his faith in the system and the upper castes, primarily Brahmins, and began pondering the reasons for their refusal to change.

Dr Ambedkar believed that the ancient Hindu law text Manu Smriti, by bestowing great powers on Brahmins and endorsing the Varna system and other inequalities, created conditions that made untouchability a sad reality of India. In burning Manu Smriti, he was hoping to attack the problem at its source.


Now comes the crucial question, was it a correct assignment of blame?

Across the length and breadth of the country we know that the Hindu society and the Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Lingayat*, Christian, and even Muslim societies that run parallel to it have (or have had) a caste system. Is India’s unique caste system a creation of (or an institution buttressed by) the Manu Smriti?

For example, is it because their Hindu ancestors read Manu Smriti morning, evening and for lunch that the Tamil Nadar Christians refused Tamil Scheduled Caste Christians entry into their churches? Is it because of Manu Smriti that a Bengali washerman doesn’t normally marry a Bengali fisher(wo)man?


I would say, respectfully, NO.

  • Manu Smriti itself doesn’t talk of untouchability, much less endorse it – the object of Babasaheb’s main focus.
  • Manu Smriti’s dictates were freely flouted. For example Manu forbids marriage between close relatives. But in South India and amongst the speakers of Dravidian languages, marriage between cross-cousins and even cross-uncle and niece is known to happen. When his dictates flouted customary law, Manu was not listened to.
  • Almost everybody confounds the Varna system – what Manu talks about – with the Jati system – India’s reality . A washerman’s caste doesn’t marry from a fisherman’s caste or a plumber caste doesn’t marry from a carpenter caste even though all belong to the same Varna. Nor would a Konkanastha historically marry a Sarasvat from the same Varna.
  • How does one explain such phenomenon as all Hindus of Pakistan (outside of a few traders) being scheduled castes? How can Pakistan with no caste Hindus have scheduled castes?
  • Similarly, how can Sri Lanka with no Brahmins among Sinhala Buddhists and a very small number of Brahmins among Tamil Hindus have a caste system?
  • Manu Smriti is revered in Cambodia, Laos, Thailand, Burma. It forms the basis of Thailand’s traditional law Thammasat. Yet these countries never had India-style caste system. How could they read the same book and not come up with Indian caste system? The answer is the root of the caste system is not in the book.

Much as I admire Dr Ambedkar for his struggles against as an entrenched system, I don’t think it is correct to hold this book responsible for the genesis of the entrenched system. That is because Hindus are simply not a people of the book.

* putting Lingayat separate since their founders were opposed to it

- advertisement -

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

Latest News

भारतीय भाषाई विविधता पर हावी पश्चिमीकरण और हमारी दुर्बलता

संस्कृत विश्व की पुरातन भाषा है और वर्तमान की सभी भाषाओं की उत्पत्ति इसी भाषा से हुई है किन्तु आज यही संस्कृत भाषा विलोपित होती जा रही है। उससे भी बड़ी विडम्बना यह है कि हम स्वयं अपनी भाषागत परंपरा का पश्चिमीकरण कर रहे हैं। (by @omdwivedi93)

COVID 19- Agonies of Odisha Sarpanches no one is talking about

While the delegation of the collector power to the Sarpanch is being welcomed by all, the mismanagement has put an woe among these people's representatives.

The implications of structural changes brought by Coronavirus – Part 1

Many companies will move towards greater share of employees working from home with a weekly one to two day gathering for team building purposes. The IT industry in India estimates that close to 50 per cent of the country’s 4.3 million IT workers will soon work from home.

Saving the idea of India

Should Mickey (Valmiki) have not been more inclusive and given name Rehman instead of Hanuman and Agatha instead of Agastya? Such bandicoot the wrier was!

Feminism is nice, but why settle for a lesser idea?

Feminism talks about only women, Devi talks about humanity and cares for everyone equally as a compassionate mother (real gender neutrality)

Centre’s Amphan package for West Bengal should be low in ‘cash’, high in ‘kind’

while helping the state, the centre must reduce the cash disbursement as much as possible. The corruption through misappropriation is believed to be directly proportional to the 'cash component' in a package.

Recently Popular

तीन ऐसे लोग जिन्होंने बताया कि पराजय अंत नहीं अपितु आरम्भ है: पढ़िए इन तीन राजनैतिक योद्धाओं की कहानी

ये तीन लोग हैं केंद्रीय मंत्री श्रीमती स्मृति ईरानी, दिल्ली भाजपा के युवा एवं ऊर्जावान नेता एवं समाजसेवी कपिल मिश्रा एवं तजिंदर पाल सिंह बग्गा। इन तीनों की कहानी बड़ी ही रोचक एवं प्रेरणादायी है।

सावधान: सोशल मीडिया का गलत इस्तेमाल कर छात्र-छात्राओं को किया जा रहा गुमराह!

अगर इन्टरनेट पर उपलब्ध जानकारियाँ गलत हो या संस्थाओं से प्रेरित हो तब तो आपका ऐसे संस्थाओं के जाल में फसना निश्चित है और इसका एहसास आपको जब होगा तब तक बहुत देर हो चुकी होगी।

Ayan invasion theory- A myth

What’s shocking to me is that a certain section of India holds up to the AIT and consistently tries to prove it right despite many genetic/ archeological/ historical evidences. Now who is that section that I am referring to ? The “left” of India.

The problem with some of the universities in India.

These liberal scholars, sitting in universities, play a game of psychology in which they repeat same things to the students everyday about a person or ideology and instil in them the same thought process as theirs.

ABVP and RSS volunteers conduct door-to-door screening of residents in Mumbai

Volunteers of ABVP and RSS began door to door screening in slum pockets of Nehru Nagar in Mumbai, equipped with PPE sets and directed by doctors on board, and screened over 500 people in total in the last three days.