Thursday, June 4, 2020
Home Opinions How the protests are making a strong case for CAA, and perhaps, NRC

How the protests are making a strong case for CAA, and perhaps, NRC

Also Read


There is a term called ‘unintended consequences’ in the social sciences. These are outcomes of purposeful actions, that are not intended or foreseen. One of the types of unintended consequences is ‘Perverse Result’, meaning, an effect contrary to what was originally intended.

The CAA protests across the country seem to have a perverse effect. Let’s look at it from a closer look.

During the debates on Citizenship Amendment Bill in Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, the Union Home Minister Mr. Amit Shah mentioned several times that this bill does NOT impact any of the existing citizens of India. He explained in great detail what it is intended for religious minorities seeking Indian Citizenship due to religious persecution in the three Islamic countries of Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh.

The country seemed to be divided during, what can be called Phase One of the CAA – introduction of the bill in both the houses of parliament, debate, voting and making it into law. But the protests that have burst out now across the country, from Delhi to Bengal to Bihar to Kerala, from AMU to Jamia have shaken the country. Perhaps the situation is in Phase Two now.

Some heart-wrenching glimpses of protests

Image result for caa trains brunt"
Just peacefully burning the trains?


The protests appeared to have started peacefully. But then the obvious thing happened. The violence. The gruesome pictures of mob violence sent shivers down the spine of the country. Trains are torched, railway stations are vandalised, buses are set on fire, etc. The Azadi slogans started surfacing. And thanks to social media. It’s all on twitter for people to see.

A logical question in the minds of the majority of Indians now: when the CAA does not deal with any of the existing citizens of India, what exactly are these “Indian Citizens” protesting?

Vandalized railway stations


As people try to find their own answers, after seeing this violence, it is possible that the public opinion is now slowly turning in favor of not only CAA but also NRC. Indians are realizing that they are sitting on a volcano of anti-social elements, who can unleash violence at the drop of a hat.  This happened several times since 1947 (e.g. 1984, 2002). The main difference between now and the past is that the nationalism interest in Indians, perhaps is at an all-time high, since independence struggle. These protests will be handled effectively in Phase Three.

The ‘Protesters’ in their uniform

The very law that the protesters are trying to oppose, because of the ‘nature of their protests’, is being considered as a must-have by the public of the country. And that’s phase four.

There you go! The perverse effect of unintended consequences!

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

Latest News

What to believe?

Our forefathers never had the EXISTENTIAL CRISIS moment this generation is having. They were too busy getting themselves out of subpar life they were in that they never had time to ask these questions or time for that matters.

आजादी मिली सिर्फ भारत के लेफ्ट में

हमें तो आप के इतिहासकारों ने इस बात की भी आजादी नहीं दी की हम महाराणा प्रताप, वीर शिवाजी के बारे में किताबों में पढ़ सके उसमें भी तो आपने भारत पर अत्याचार और चढ़ाई करने वालों की जिंदगी के बारे में लिख दी कि वो ही इस महान देश के कर्ता धर्ता थे।

एक मुख्यमंत्री जो भली भांति जानता है कि संकट को अवसर में किस प्रकार परिवर्तित करना है: भारत के सर्वाधिक लोकप्रिय मुख्यमंत्री के प्रयासों...

भारत के इन सेक्युलर, लिबरल और वामपंथियों को यह रास नहीं आया कि भगवा धारण करने वाला एक हिन्दू सन्यासी कैसे भारत के सबसे बड़े राज्य का प्रशासक हो सकता है। लेकिन यह हुआ।

2020 अमेरिका का सब से खराब साल बनने जा रहा है? पहले COVID-19 और फिर दंगे

America फिर से जल रहा है: आंशिक रूप से, जैसा कि हिंसा भड़कती है, पुलिस और उनके वाहनों पर हमला किया जाता...

Corona and a new breed of social media intellectuals

Opposing an individual turned into opposing betterment of your own country and countrymen.

Why peaceful borders with India pose a threat to Pakistan’s sovereignty

Although a religion may have some influence on the culture of the society as a whole but it can never disassociate an individual from the much broader way of life which defines culture. Indonesia is a great example of the above stated distinction.

Recently Popular

रचनाधर्मियों को गर्भस्थ बेटी का उत्तर

जो तुम्हें अग्नि परीक्षा देती असहाय सीता दिखती है, वो मुझे प्रबल आत्मविश्वास की धनी वो योद्धा दिखाई देती है जिसने रावण के आत्मविश्वास को छलनी कर इस धरा को रावण से मुक्त कराया.

The one difference between the Congress of today and that of before 2014

For the sake of the future generations, for the sake of our children, please read more books about how Congress had been ruling the country and be aware of the dangers.

Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul was right to call out rising intolerance

The libertarians need to know free speech is not licence for hate speech. Our fundamental rights are not akin to First Amendment Rights, as in the US. There are reasonable restrictions and they have a purpose.

श्रमिकों का पलायन: अवधारणा

अंत में जब कोविड 19 के दौर में श्रमिक संकट ने कुछ दबी वास्तविकताओं से दो चार किया है. तो क्यों ना इस संकट को अवसर में बदल दिया जाए.

Easing lockdown a gamble?

If we want to compare economic condition and job loss due to lockdown and blame the govt., we ought to compare the mortality rate too, which one of the lowest in the world at around 2.83%!