Saturday, June 6, 2020
Home Opinions Tanmay Bhatt episode: Selective Outrage and Glorification of the Offender

Tanmay Bhatt episode: Selective Outrage and Glorification of the Offender

Also Read

Liberal Right
#philosophy #perception #rightpolitics #behavioraleconomics #organizedreligion #wwbd

Since the renaissance, societies across the world have been progressive on many fronts like culture, religion, social customs etc. Many concepts are considered progressive and progressiveness is considered good. Once such concept is Individualism. Societies are now increasingly becoming individualistic. Individual freedom is of utmost importance. Like everything, individualism also has pros and cons. But right now, I am not going into those details.

One offshoot of individualism is personal freedom. Freedom to choose what you think is good for you. This kind of freedom starts with legal age to drink alcohol, eat tobacco, to marry etc. There is a notion that after certain age, humans develop certain kind of intelligence, certain physical features so he/she is capable of thinking and doing what is good for him/her. It is all together different debate about the validity of this notion.

Another such concept is freedom of expression/speech and right to offend. In good old days, kids were taught to respect elders. Now they are taught such concepts like right to offend. Personally, I believe there should be FoE/FoS and right to offend. Conceptually, there is nothing inherently bad about it. But as with every other good provisions, people misuse it to spread venom in society and get away with it.

Let me come to some specifics. Recently in India, a comedian named Tanmay Bhat made a short video using Snapchat and insulted two icons: Sachin Tendulkar and Lata Mangeshkar. An uproar followed soon after on social and electronic media from both sides. Those who opposes Tanmay are mostly from the so called right wing parties with orthodox mindset. And those who oppose Tanmay-basher are mostly with so called liberal mindset and progressive values.

I am of the opinion that anybody should be allowed to rant whatever he/she wants. I do believe in FoE/FoS. But still I don’t want to identify myself with people who have ‘liberal’ mindset for two reasons:

First, they recall such freedoms selectively. Few months ago, a person named Kamlesh Tiwari expressed his views on Prophet Mohammed. Those views have offended Muslim community. There was a large scale violent protest against Kamlesh Tiwari. The community wants to hang Kamlesh Tiwari for such a ‘crime’. Kamlesh Tiwari was arrested and now is in jail for hate speech. From that time till now, not a single ‘liberal’ has said anything in favor of him or his freedom of speech. The same liberals who are now defending Tanmay (Tanmay has made very derogatory remarks on Ganeshji in the past) have not spoken a single word in favor of Kamlesh Tiwari’s right to free speech.


Second, they glorify the person who was exercising free speech right to abuse others. Legally, the person has every right to express his/her views. But when you abuse these rights to mock someone, it is not acceptable socially or morally. Using profanity and derogatory remarks for others regardless of their ability, political affinity or ideology are not good things.

In an article defending Tanmay Bhat’s act, they have written All India Bakc***. Surely, they can spell the whole word instead of putting ‘*’. There would be nothing illegal in that, but still they refrain from doing so. Because even they realize that there should be some decency. Whatever you can do legally does not mean what you are doing is acceptable.

No, I will not file an FIR or campaign to ban the video, but definitely people like Tanmay are not my heroes. I register my protest against such act.

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

Liberal Right
#philosophy #perception #rightpolitics #behavioraleconomics #organizedreligion #wwbd

Latest News

हिन्द उवाच

है लहू मिला जिस मिट्टी में, बिस्मिल, अशफ़ाक़, भगतसिंह का। जिसको स्वेदों से सींचा है, गाँधी और लाल बहादुर ने।

From a porcupine to a tiger – Advent of Modi sarkar

The Modi government has established a brand India, enveloping components of economy, diplomacy, revival of foreign affairs and a clean-up of corrupt-ridden governance of the past; dispensed from an establishment with little obligation to coalition partners that enjoys mandate and confidence of the citizenry of India

Has social service become a way of conversion?

Christian Missionaries blackmail vulnerable people to choose between being able to follow their traditions and being able to feed their family. In desperate times, many people convert.

Tiananmen massacre to communist attacks on Indian people: A saga of hate, hypocrisy and violence

Tiananmen remains one of the most sensitive and taboo subjects in China today, banned from both academic and popular realms.

George Floyd and India

Ashok Swain, who is a professor in Sweden’s Uppsala’s University was upset that such protest doesn’t happen in India, so did another ‘journalist’ Rana Ayyub. Instead of showing solidarity with a man who lost his life, these opportunists are provoking vandalism and mayhem in India too.

बौद्ध मत की वो बातें, जो बताई नहीं जाती

कोई कॉमरेड और नवबौद्ध आपको देवराज इंद्र से जुड़ी हुई ये बातें नहीं बताएगा. वास्तविकता तो यह है कि बौद्ध ग्रंथों में देवराज इंद्र का उतना ही वर्णन है, जितना हिन्दू ग्रंथों में मिलता है.

Recently Popular

रचनाधर्मियों को गर्भस्थ बेटी का उत्तर

जो तुम्हें अग्नि परीक्षा देती असहाय सीता दिखती है, वो मुझे प्रबल आत्मविश्वास की धनी वो योद्धा दिखाई देती है जिसने रावण के आत्मविश्वास को छलनी कर इस धरा को रावण से मुक्त कराया.

Easing lockdown a gamble?

If we want to compare economic condition and job loss due to lockdown and blame the govt., we ought to compare the mortality rate too, which one of the lowest in the world at around 2.83%!

The journey of anti-CAA virus in the U.S.: A tale of three cities

Kshama Sawant, a Hindu immigrant embraces Hindu phobic ideology and lead an anti-India campaign to seek a stage for her future political dreams.

भारत-चीन पर राहुल का सवाल

भारत ही नेहरू के नेतृत्व में पहला गैर साम्यवादी जनतांत्रिक राज्य था जिसने जनवादी कम्युनिस्ट चीन को मान्यता प्रदान की. नेहरू उस दौर में चीन को लेकर इतने रोमांटिक (कल्पनावादी) हो गए थे कि तिब्बत पर चीन का आधिपत्य स्वीकार कर लिया. पर जब 1962 में चीन ने भारत पर हमला किया तो नेहरू की विदेश नीति चौपट हो गई थी.

Corona and a new breed of social media intellectuals

Opposing an individual turned into opposing betterment of your own country and countrymen.