Monday, August 10, 2020
Home Reports Growing tensions between India and Nepal over 'Kalapani' issue

Growing tensions between India and Nepal over ‘Kalapani’ issue

Also Read

Rahul Das
M.Phil Scholar of International Relations, Jadavpur University. Gold medalist, MA, Political Science, Rabindra Bharati University. Exploring various fields of Political writing. A news junkie with the keen interest in political & social issues. Freelance Journo. Authored numerous articles in many national and international journals.
 

The new map is going to replace the old map of Nepal. The new map claims that the 335 sq km area of Kalapani, Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura is located in Nepal, but the area is still in India. This region has been appearing on the Indian map for ages. The bill on this issue has been passed in the lower house of the Nepal Parliament. It is evident that the matters is gradually getting out of the reach of India. Once the national emblem of Nepal is placed on this new map, there will be no way to correct it.

Addressing BJP members in Uttarakhand on June 15, Indian Defence Minister Rajnath Singh spoke of the strength of bilateral relations between India and Nepal. He said “Our army has Gorkha Regiment whose soldiers have displayed valour and courage on numerous times for the country. Its war cry is ‘Jai Mahakali Aayo Re Gorkhali (Hail Mother Kali, here comes the Gorkha) and Mahakali is also the in Kolkata, Kamakhya and Vindhyachal with devotees all around India. Then how can the ties between the two countries break?” Singh further added in his speech, “India-Nepal ties are not an ordinary one. We have a relation of ‘Roti and Beti’ which cannot be broken by any power of the world.” He said India’s differences with Nepal over these three places could be resolved through dialogue.

Singh made the remark two days after the bill to amend the constitution was passed in the lower house of Nepal’s Parliament. The bill will now be passed in The Upper house of the Nepal Parliament. It will then be sent to the President of Nepal. Once he signs, the new map will be recognised instead of the old one.

Ever since Nepal took the initiative to change the map, India has been saying that this unilateral decision of Nepal is not acceptable. Ignoring India’s objections, Nepal is moving towards its own goal. On the day the bill was passed in the lower house of the Nepal’s parliament, the old statement of the Indian Ministry of External Affairs were repeated. Later Rajnath Singh was careful enough in his statement. It is clear that India does not want a repeat of the deteriorating relations with Nepal in the past, especially what happened in September 2015.

According to the 1950 agreement, no passport is required to cross the border between the two countries, historically, India has a good rapport with Nepal, even there are no fences on the borders of the two countries, people move freely here. The relations between the two countries are smooth expect for a few regional issues. In the context of such peaceful relations between the two countries, this border dispute between them is completely undesirable. But history does not follow in one’s own way.

With the end of monarchy in Nepal, the rise of Communists, the disagreement with India over the drafting of a new constitution, relations between the two countries took a new turn. Besides, Nepal’s growing closeness with China has become a headache for India. India-Nepal relations have become more toxic with the controversy over the new map of Nepal. Now the future of the relationship will depend on the prudence of the leadership of these two countries and the generosity of China.
Nepal has never raised the demand for Kalapani, Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura so strongly. Historically, India’s claim to the area has been predominant.

 

In 1815, the King of Nepal signed the ‘Treaty of Sugauli’ with the East India company, which was ratified in 1816. According to this treaty Nepal got the right to the east Bank of Mahakali river and India got the right to the west bank. This position has remained unchanged for a long time. The beginning of the argument centres on the identification of the source of the Mahakali river in the Nepali interpretation. Nepal’s explanation is that the region which India considers to be the source of the Mahakali river is not the actual source of the Mahakali river at all. So, the location of Kalapani, Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura is not in Pithoragarh of India but in Dharchula district of Nepal.

It is difficult for India to accede to Nepal’s claim, as it is stated in several documents apart from the Sugauli Agreement that the real owner of the region is India. During China’s invasion of Tibet in 1950s, India set up 17-18 military posts on the Chinese border with Nepal’s permission. In 1969, at the behest of king Mahendra of Nepal, Prime Minister Kirti Nidhi Bista asked Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi to remove these Army posts. Kalapani was not among the list of Army posts that Nepal gave to India at that time. Now the question is why Kalapani was not in this list? Nepal’s explanation for this question is that King Mahendra was aware of India’s security concerns, so at India’s request, he allowed the Indian Army to maintain an Army post at Kalapani.

Incidentally, Kalapani is the entrance to the Lipulekh pass. Is this interpretation of Nepal acceptable at all? China did not pay attention to this area in 1969. Also, the cultural revolution in China was at its peak at that time. It was not clear why Indira Gandhi would request Raja Mahendra to let India’s army post stay at Kalapani. And there is no historical document of Nepal’s claim. The baselessness of Nepal’s claim proves that India had set up an army post in Kalapani as per the previous treaty. There was no question of seeking permission from the king separately.

 

Why is Nepal suddenly so eager to occupy this region? The reason for this to be found in the incompetence of India’s foreign policy and China’s incitement against India. Khadga Prasad Sharma Oli, known as a staunch anti-Indian, became the Prime Minister of Nepal after the two communist parties merged at the initiative of China . Maoist leaders Prachanda and Madhav Kumar Nepal gradually became his challengers. Oli was rapidly losing popularity among the people of Nepal due to administrative failure. Although Oli was in post, the people were repeatedly demanding a change of Prime Minister. During this turmoil, India released a new map of Jammu and Kashmir in November 2019. The inclusion of Kalapani in this map gives Oli a new impetus to oppose India.

On May 8, Indian Defence Minister Rajnath Singh inaugurated the Mansarovar Link Road, in which Oli got another weapon to criticise India . In 2005, India decided to build a 80 km long road to ease the difficult and inaccessible road to Mansarovar. The cost was estimated as 80 crore. The road, which was supposed to be completed in 2013, was inaugurated in May 2020. By then, the cost has gone up to 440 crore. After the inauguration, Oli raised his voice against India. He adopted well-known anti-India tactics to handle mass protest in his own country. He stated that “Those who are coming from India through illegal channels are spreading the virus in the country…………Indian virus looks more lethal than Chinese and Italian now.” Immediately after his statement, a new map of Nepal was released.

Leaving Prachanda and Madhav behind by cunning political tactics, Oli will be relieved for a while now.
What should India do now in this situation? Experts think that India has to proceed very carefully this time. It would be foolish for India to take the kind of action it took at the time of Madheshi problem. In other words, India should not take any decision like blockade. If a hasty decision like blockade is taken, the result will be fatal. But, India has to be adamant in its demand for Kalapani, as the historical documents are in India’s favour. Moreover, Nepal has not closed the door for talks yet. Nepal has formed a nine member expert team whose job is to present evidence in support of Nepal’s claim. India has no choice but to resolve the issue politically and diplomatically without hurting the Nepali national sentiment.

In the last six years, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi may have brought the world leadership closer, but India’s distance from its neighbours is widening. The further India moves away from its neighbours, the close China becomes to them. Nepal is the biggest example of this. India’s proximity with its closest and most trusted neighbour Bangladesh, is also waning. At present, it is necessary for the Indian leadership to think openly about this issue.

It is important to remember that Oli has followed the path shown by Modi. Oli played the nationalist card in this case, which Modi played during the surgical strikes on Pakistan. With this single weapon, Oli silenced the opposition, charmed the masses and blunted the ‘big brotherly’ arrogance of India. India has no choice but to remain flexible at the moment. As much as this move has brought Oli’s success as a politician, it has also exposed India’s diplomatic failure.

Nepal created a Kashmir-like situation for India with the Kalapani region. Kashmir is fragmented on India’s map to Pakistan and China. The new map of Nepal will also be a cause for concern for India. Because in this new map, even if it is small, a crack will be found in Uttarakhand region. The issue is being handled very carefully by Indian leadership but it is still difficult to heal this wound.

Nepal Parliament approves new map that includes land India claims. 18 June 2020. Aljazeera.
Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2020/06/nepal-parliament-approves-map-includes-land-india-claims-200618074902407.html

Chaudhury, Dipanjan R, 21 May 2020. Indian Coronavirus more lethal than Chinese : Nepal PM K P Sharma Oli, Economic Times.
Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.economictimes.com/news/international/world-news/coronavirus-coming-from-india-more-lethal-than-those-from-china-italy-oli/amp_articleshow/75850117.cms

Ministry of External Affairs. 31 July 1950. Treaty of Peace and Friendship. Kathmandu,
Retrieved from https://mea.gov.in/bilateral-documents.htm?dtl/6295/Treaty+of+Peace+and+Friendship

Pant, Harsh V, 17 October 2019, China-Nepal ties are deepening. What can India Do?. Daily O, Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailyo.in/lite/politics/china-nepal-relations-xi-jinpiing-tibet-hong-kong-protests/story/1/32094.html

Treaty of Sugauli, Wikipedia. Retrieved from https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Sugauli

Mazumdar, Jaideep. 20 March 2030. Explained : How The Dispute With Nepal Over Kalapani Is A Legacy Of I K Gujral’s Misplaced Altruism. Swarajya. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/swarajyamag.com/amp/story/politics%252Fexplained-how-the-dispute-with-nepal-over-kalapani-is-a-legacy-of-i-k-gujrals-misplaced-altruism

Saran, Shyam. 12 July 2020. As Nepal paints itself into a corner on Kalapani issue. India must tread carefully. The Indian Express. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/india-nepal-new-map-kalapani-6454647/lite/

Siddique, Maha. 20 May 2020, India Says Won’t Accept ‘Artificial’ Enlargement of Territorial Claims’ after Nepal Releases New Map. News 18. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.news18.com/amp/news/world/nepal-releases-new-map-including-limpiyadhura-lipulekh-and-kalapani-under-its-territory-2629199.html

China Welcomes The Merger of Nepal’s Two Communist Parties. 18 May 2018. Spotlight. Retrieved from https://www.spotlightnepal.com/2018/05/18/china-welcomes-merger-nepals-two-communist-parties/

Thousands in Nepal Protest against cultural ‘guthi’ bill. 19 June 2019. Aljazeera. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2019/06/thousands-nepal-protest-cultural-guthi-bill-190619121216425.html

Nepal strongly objects to Kalapani area being included in India as part of new map, says Kathmandu. 07 November 2019. Firstpost. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.firstpost.com/india/nepal-strongly-objects-to-kalapani-area-being-included-in-india-as-part-of-new-map-says-kathmandu-7614281.html/amp

Peri, Dinkar. 08 May 2020. Rajnath Singh inaugurates new road to Kailash Mansarovar. The Hindu. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.thehindu.com/news/national/rajnath-singh-inaugurates-new-road-to-kailash-mansarovar/article31533372.ece/amp/

Nepal Protests India’s New Road to Lipulekh ;’Entirely Within Territory’, Responds New Delhi. 09 May 2020, The Wire. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.thewire.in/article/external/day-after-india-unveils-link-road-to-lipulekh-nepal-protests-unilateral-act/amp

Chaudhury, Dipanjan R. 21 May 2020. Indian Coronavirus more lethal than Chinese : Nepal PM KP Sharma Oli, Economic Times. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.economictimes.com/news/international/world-news/coronavirus-coming-from-india-more-lethal-than-those-from-china-italy-oli/amp_articleshow/75850117.cms

Chari, Seshadri. 18 January 2020. As Modi Govt doubles down on CAA, long-term friend Bangladesh moves closer to China. The Print. Retrieved from https://www.google.com/amp/s/theprint.in/opinion/as-modi-govt-doubles-down-on-caa-long-time-friend-bangladesh-moves-closer-to-china/351354/%3famp

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

Rahul Das
M.Phil Scholar of International Relations, Jadavpur University. Gold medalist, MA, Political Science, Rabindra Bharati University. Exploring various fields of Political writing. A news junkie with the keen interest in political & social issues. Freelance Journo. Authored numerous articles in many national and international journals.

Latest News

All that’s online isn’t gospel

Everybody has an opinion about every small issue around him, thanks to the information available at a finger click, no matter how valid it is!

Learnings from Galwan Valley– Similarities between Nazi Germany and Communist China

Has China committed a grave error of judgement in picking a fight with India in the Galwan valley? And will it exhibit the reckless aggressiveness of Hitler or the shrewd cunning of the famed Chinese military strategist Sun Tzu ?

मंदिरों के देश में न्याय मांगते मंदिर

आइए जानते हैं कुछ प्रमुख मंदिरों के बारे में जो आज मस्जिद का रूप लिए हुए हैं और न्याय मांग रहे हैं।

Politics of religion and science

Since BJP made history in 2014 and came to power with staggering numbers, there has been constant propaganda about religion taking importance over development and science.

Once nurturer, America is a hoarder of talent now

The allure of the American Dream is now a net negative for H1B workers and the Global community.

Thinning the line between natural & man-made disasters

As climate change and unsustainable development have become totems of environmental deterioration, humanity continues to incur the wrath of nature through an uneven distribution of rainfall, longer than usual spells of drought, and frequent earthquakes.

Recently Popular

आदिवासी दिवस के बहाने अलगाववाद की राजनीति

दिवासी अथवा जनजातियों को उनके अधिकार दिलाने की मुहिम दिखने वाला "आदिवासी दिवस" नाम का यह आयोजन ऊपर से जितना सामान्य और साधारण दिखाई देता है वो उससे कहीं अधिक उलझा हुआ है।

Two nation theory after independence

Two Nation Theory was the basis of partition of India. Partition was accepted based on the assumption that the Muslims staying back in India because they rejected the Two Nation theory. However, later decades proved that Two Nation Theory is not only subscribed by a large section of Indian Muslims but also being nourished by the appeasement politics.

Are Indian history text books really biased?

Contributions of many dynasties, kings and kingdoms find no mention in our text books. Post independence history is also not adequately covered in our text books.

Striking similarities between the death of Parveen Babi and Sushant Singh Rajput: A mere co-incidence or well planned murders?

Together Rhea and Bhatt’s media statements subtly and cleverly project Sushant as some kind of a nut job like Parveen Babi, another Bhatt conjuring.

The story of Lord Jagannath and Krishna’s heart

But do we really know the significance of this temple and the story behind the incomplete idols of Lord Jagannath, Lord Balabhadra and Maa Shubhadra?
Advertisements