Sunday, September 20, 2020
Home Opinions LeLis continue to falter: Want to know the science behind it?

LeLis continue to falter: Want to know the science behind it?

Also Read

 

The LeLis (left-liberals) of India are devastated. They seem to be incapacitated profoundly than ever in the past.

Why?

Because they predicted the mood of the nation wrong (you may say that’s typical, but we will park it for now). They could not see what was right in front of them. Although the lesion (prediction itself) was small, the agony (that they got it wrong) was unbearable. They became victims of a psychological phenomenon called ‘confirmation bias’. Interesting? Read on.

Scott Plous presented this idea in his famous book ‘The psychology of judgment and decision making’. He discussed various questions- “how do people make decisions? How do they sift through the information without drowning in a sea of alternatives? And what are the factors that lead them in a certain direction?” In the quest to answer these questions, he presented the idea of ‘confirmation bias’ – the tendency to search for, interpret, favor, and recall information in a way that confirms one’s preexisting beliefs or hypotheses!

Too technical?  Let me simplify it for you.

Confirmation bias is, in simple words, bias. Analysis typically happens in three levels: a) gathering information, b) remembering information, and c) interpreting information. When people are obsessed with certain ideologies, bias creeps into their analysis. They collect data according to their bias. They selectively remember facts. As a result, their interpretation is generally flawed. This effect is much stronger for desired outcomes, emotionally charged issues, and for deeply entrenched beliefs.  

 

The 2019 general elections perfectly fit the bill. The LeLis were frustrated with what they perceived as right-wing politics and wanted to get back to the so-called secular roots (desired-outcome). The abuses that were hurled in the campaign establish the fact that all the parties are emotionally charged. In their mind, 2019 was an ideological war between their deeply entrenched beliefs and an ideology that they perceived as a threat to India’s secular and constitutional fabric.

Although all the parties looked at the same evidence, the disagreement became more extreme.  This is called ‘attitude polarization’. Let’s look at two examples.

Firstly, Swachh Bharat Abhiyan. It is a nationwide campaign in India to improve overall hygiene and cleanliness in the country. One of its main aims was to achieve an open-defecation free India by 2019 by constructing 90 million toilets at a whopping USD 30 billion expense. The government has built 86 million toilets since 2014, reducing the number of people who openly defecate from over 550 million to under 150 million by 2018.

 

During the election season, there were studies done and surveys that showed many people still do not use the toilets. The SBM campaign has been sharply criticized for using coercive approaches to force people to use toilets.  And so on.

This is where the ‘attitude polarization’ took effect. The government looked at the data and declared that the mission is pretty much on its way to achieve its stated goals with providing this service to over 400 million people. However, the same data is perceived by LeLis differently. They termed the mission to be a failure attributing to the facts such as toilets were built, but there was no water to use them, or people who defecate in the open were shamed, bullied, denied ration, or even in some extreme cases, were arrested.  

Talk about ‘looking at the same evidence, drawing completely different conclusions!

While there is no argument about the fact that there is much to achieve in the Swachh Bharat Mission, completely dismissing the work done has adversely impacted the conclusions. That is precisely what has happened here. The confirmation bias crept into LeLis’ analysis at all the levels- information gathering, remembering, and interpreting. The fact that the common man of the country witnessed the delivery of a promise, without having to pay any bribe, perhaps happened for the first time in independent India. This big picture was lost due to confirmation bias in the LeLis’ analysis.

Another example is the Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana. The scheme was launched in 2016 to distribute 50 million LPG connections to women of BPL (below poverty line) families. The number crossed 58 million by 2018, and the government has redefined the scope to reach out to 80 million poor households. Over 40% of the beneficiaries were families belonging to the scheduled caste and tribes. The scheme led to an increase in LPG consumption by 56% in 2019 as compared to 2014.

And then there were studies, surveys, and reports published on how the scheme was a failure.  Data was sliced and diced to support this conclusion. Several arguments were made in its favor like the number of gas connections were rising faster than the sales of LPG cylinders, the average number of cylinders used in a year has come down, over 37% of the households in rural areas procure cooking fuel for free, etc.  

This led to one sweeping conclusion: that the poor were not able to afford the cost of LPG refills and that the scheme has failed.

This is where the aspect of interpreting ambiguous evidence as supporting their existing position comes into play. The LeLis’ beliefs persisted in spite of the contrary evidence. This condition is called ‘belief perseverance’ in psychology. It is further supported by the irrational primacy effect where people tend to rely significantly on information encountered early in a series.

And thus they missed the bus. As it happened in the case of Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, people perhaps for the first time since independence, experienced delivery of a promise, without having to pay any bribe. The LPG cylinder is right there, in front of them, in their kitchen. Yes, it is true that the pricing model should be made better. And yes, it is true that the money-making-opportunities for the poor and oppressed should improve. But that does not negate the fact of physical delivery of the service.

If you were to analyze the other issues of the election raised by the LeLis, the agrarian distress, lack of jobs, breakdown of the institutions, you find a pattern. As long as the LeLis live in denial, their predictions are not going to get any better. They are going to be disconnected from the ground realities. Although they use data to support their arguments, their analysis conclusions are impacted due to confirmation bias, attitude polarisation, and belief perseverance.

That’s folks, living in a fool’s paradise. And one day, forced to wake up to a sudden, rude, shocking reality.

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

Latest News

“UPSC Jihad”: A tale of ignominious judicial capriciousness

The Indian judiciary appears to lose all semblance of nuance so soon as the word, “minority” appears. This is yet another problem in the Hollow Republic of India — and I use that term after prodigious consideration.

Bappa Rawal – The legend untold

Bappa Rawal in a sense had broken the myth that Indian Kings could not unite against foreign invaders to protect the mother land. The fake narrative to divide and derecognize them has been in history books for too long

वो यात्रा जो सफलता से अधिक संघर्ष बयाँ करती है

आज भारत विश्व में अपनी नई पहचान के साथ आगे बढ़ रहा है। वो भारत जो कल तक गाँधी का भारत था जिसकी पहचान उसकी सहनशीलता थी, आज मोदी का भारत है जो खुद पहल करता नहीं, किसी को छेड़ता नहीं लेकिन अगर कोई उसे छेड़े तो छोड़ता भी नहीं।

One nation, one market 2020: Will the dream come true?

New policies of Modi govt for farmers is for their betterment. However, as always, the opposition just does not want the farmers to be better.

Lessons from Sweden

What happened after seventy years, which is making Europe moving for right wing and Nationalism again? Why is a country like Sweden today feeling the heat? What changed in past decade that made liberal society to change?

Mirror of self-discovery in pandemic

This year has been really horrific. Obnoxious amount of sadness, sickness and death. Nature forced us to confront ourselves in a lot many ways. But hope prevails. The waves of faith keep crashing the beach.

Recently Popular

5 Cases where True Indology exposed Audrey Truschke

Her claims have been busted, but she continues to peddle her agenda

Mughals are NOT Indians

In this article we analyse whether Mughals were Indians or invaders who stayed because of the vast wealth and resources and also the power it gave them in the Islamic world.

Daredevil of Indian Army: Para SF Major Mohit Sharma’s who became Iftikaar Bhatt to kill terrorists

Such brave souls of Bharat Mata who knows every minute of their life may become the last minute.

Digital service delivery will bolster an Atmanirbhar Bharat

A clear vision of the Digital India program has stimulated the efficiency of digital service delivery by ensuring development at the grassroots level via the formulation of 796 digital villages and more than 3.6 lakh functional common services centers offering digital access points for the delivery of essential public utility services

पोषण अभियान: सही पोषण – देश रोशन

भारत सरकार द्वारा कुपोषण को दूर करने के लिए जीवनचक्र एप्रोच अपनाकर चरणबद्ध ढंग से पोषण अभियान चलाया जा रहा है, भारत...
Advertisements