Wednesday, October 28, 2020
Home Reports The Social Dilemma!

The Social Dilemma!

Also Read

jknandahttp://www.jknanda.in
Kindly visit my website www.jknanda.in

The Social Dilemma, the new Netflix documentary, tells a story most of us are familiar with, but conveys it with scalding urgency. What are we submitting to, as we sleepwalk through our lives, staring at our screens, twitching to our notifications? What will it take to wake up?

Silicon Valley insiders, engineers, ethicists, investors, and scholars describe how the internet has been taken over by social media oligopolies, and their power to change the very fabric of our reality. Whether it is Google, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, or Snapchat, these “attention merchants” are in the business of harvesting our minds, hacking our psychologies, to sell to us more efficiently. We give ourselves away with every click, we are mercilessly profiled, and we are bought and sold: to advertisers, corporations, political actors, anyone who profits from it.

Why does this matter, and why aren’t we resisting this manipulation? Because it’s so very pleasant, like being on drugs. Social media companies exploit our own hardwired human need to speak and listen to others, to care about social approval. And once we’re hooked, they experiment on us. A range of persuasive technologies is turned on – every morning, we are prompted to think thoughts we didn’t intend to, because of our phone’s notifications. Every “pull and refresh” that bridges new content is like the thrill of playing a slot machine, every tagged photo is a fresh dose. When you see bubbles that show someone is typing, it magnetizes your attention. These are not choices we consciously make, they suck us in at deeper, helpless level. Social media platforms know each of us minutely, can predict our tendencies, and can also mold our behaviour at scale.

Does this seem exaggerated? After all, every new technology has caused a moral panic, including the telephone and the television. But this time it’s different, warns the documentary. With exponential increases in processing power, this is a whole new species of power and influences, with artificial intelligence and constantly learning algorithms. You and I don’t stand a chance against a phenomenal machine that knows everything about us, it’s not a fair fight. Steve Jobs once spoke of the Internet as a “bicycle for the mind”, a benevolent tool that enhances human capacities – but these platforms are not our tools, we are their tools.

It didn’t have to turn out this way. Those in their 30s or older still remember the magic of the internet before this hyper-commodification, what a generous resource and community it used to be. There are still traces of that old humane ethic; Lanier points to Wikipedia, where all of us see the same information, it is not spying and calculating and giving us our own customised reality.

While we know, in concept, that social media locks us into our own echo chambers, we don’t quite understand what this means. The Social Dilemma jolts us into realising how our realities are composed of a stream of thoughts. If you and I are fed content meant to pander our own personal enthusiasms and trigger our fears, fake or real, then soon we come to inhabit entirely different realities. We don’t even realise that others are not seeing what we are seeing. That explains why political differences, arguments over climate change or coronavirus, seem so bitter and intractable now. Our shared truths, our common sense, the very basis for reason and compromise, are being shredded because of the commercial imperatives of social media platforms.

The documentary recognises that the problem is not the technology itself, but the social forces that it amplifies. A handful of Silicon Valley platforms have become the richest companies in the history of humanity, threatening democracy. Extractive capitalism is built not to care about the effects, just as it recklessly mined the earth and destroyed entire species, it has now turned on us.

When tech barons now say “data is the new oil”, they mean that this time, our humanity is the basis of their profits. For all the fine reassurances of tech CEOs, this danger is hard for them to roll back. Algorithms cannot restore the truth, they have no way of knowing it. There is continuous pressure on them to grow, shareholder interests to consider. Recovering control has to come from us, from massive public determination. As individuals, we can make small tweaks, pay for services, turn off notifications, erect privacy barriers. Governments must realign their financial incentives- by taxing data collection or data assets or regulating them as privately owned infrastructure.

Can this be done? When confronted with the concentrated power of those companies, and the fragile grip of democratic institutions, the status quo seems overbearing. But the future is open, all change depends on the hell we raise now. And the last line of The Social Dilemma puts it simply: “We have to”.

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

jknandahttp://www.jknanda.in
Kindly visit my website www.jknanda.in
- Advertisement -

Latest News

50 shades of Dhritarashtra in Election Commission

Looking at the functioning of the grand old Indian National Congress (INC) party and the Gandhis, one has to wonder if EC has any concern for political parties' internal democracy or their integrity.

Should Marriage age of girls be increased or not: Where is Hindu voice in it?

Before taking any decision the government needs a fresh data set from different perspectives. Then later identification of the right set of gaps and needs related to marriage, pregnancy and population.

Sanatan advanced technology in temples (part-2)

The Vitthal temple of Hampi is a famous tourist attraction, not only because it is a historical temple, which has splendid architecture like the other temples, but it has also some of the wonders which are still a mystery to the world. Out of these, the musical pillars are very famous.

Recommender systems and their great baggage

What is so interesting about this term? What do they imply? Do they deserve our concern? Before we get into that, let’s dive deeper into its connection with our day to day lives.

Balkanization of a failed state: Pakistan

With over 57% of the illiterate population, no development, no infrastructure spending, soaring inflation and deficient energy security, Pakistan is a ticking time bomb.

Is caste system an integral part of Hinduism?

It is necessary to demolish the myth that caste system is an intrinsic part of Hinduism. Moreover, this myth has harmed relations between the so-called upper castes and lower castes.

Recently Popular

Is caste system an integral part of Hinduism?

It is necessary to demolish the myth that caste system is an intrinsic part of Hinduism. Moreover, this myth has harmed relations between the so-called upper castes and lower castes.

Save Hindus, save Bengali

Since 1979 the Hindus living in Meghalaya are consider a third class citizen, being the domicile and being minority religious community of the same state they have to go through a lot of unjust and equality, they cant buy land, can't get government administration jobs even can't live peacefully.

सामाजिक भेदभाव: कारण और निवारण

भारत में व्याप्त सामाजिक असामानता केवल एक वर्ग विशेष के साथ जिसे कि दलित कहा जाता है के साथ ही व्यापक रूप से प्रभावी है परंतु आर्थिक असमानता को केवल दलितों में ही व्याप्त नहीं माना जा सकता।

Should Marriage age of girls be increased or not: Where is Hindu voice in it?

Before taking any decision the government needs a fresh data set from different perspectives. Then later identification of the right set of gaps and needs related to marriage, pregnancy and population.

गुप्त काल को स्वर्ण युग क्यों कहा जाता है

एक सफल शासन की नींव समुद्रगप्त ने अपने शासनकाल में ही रख दी थी इसीलिए गुप्त सम्राटों का शासन अत्यधिक सफल रहा। साम्राज्य की दृढ़ता शांति और नागरिकों की उन्नति इसके प्रमाण थे।