Saturday, December 5, 2020
Home Opinions Constitutional threat to secularism in India

Constitutional threat to secularism in India

Also Read

Lion Heart
We The People are divided by religion but United by one Identity which is indian. We bleed for the freedom of Indians who belongs to every community and religion. The Brotherhood of Indians can't be divided on the basis of religion and we must ensure it will never. Jai Hind

In 1948 KT Shah advocated the admission of secular, socialist and federal words in Indian Preamble which in response Dr B.R Ambedkar replied “Puting Socialist words in the Constitution will restrict future policy makers in choosing a better social economic policy like capitalism and others.

During this time When Soviets advocating more and more socialist states if we adopt socialist word in preamble it will send a negative message to the world the we are on the side on Soviets which will affect our relationship with Western Europe especially America”, Directive Principle Of State policy already has the similar characteristics which Socialism advocate in this case adding Socialist word is just extra unnecessary work.

The Constituent Assembly wanted to create a secular state but concerned about the type of secularism if we insert it in the Constitution due to the fact secularism has different meanings and understanding across borders like in France Secularism restricts the aspects of religion while the US Constitution allows free expression of Religion.

In 1976 Swaran Singh committee recommendations were implemented by the Indira Government which was not yet challenged with full motivation.

If we look the legality of secular and socialist words in terms of constitution and constitution related cases we find that in two scenarios- 42th amendment in which secular and socialist words in preamble can legally be challenged.

Keshvananda Bharti case

Supreme Court said in the feature of Constitution that “Protect the Secular value of Constitution” As we all know the word Socialist, Secular introduced in preamble in 1975 on that basis it can be challenged in court that “The removal of Secular word from Constitution doesn’t affect the secular value of Constitution due to the fact in 1973 Supreme Court already said Our Constitution is Secular and adding a word isn’t worth it.”

This words introduced during that time when Constitution was suspended, any amendment between that time period is unconstitutional due to the fact Indira Gandhi wasn’t a Prime Minister during that time as per Allahabad court who said “She has to resign”.

This arguments are capable to illustration that the introduction of secular word was unnecessary and unconstitutional.

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

Lion Heart
We The People are divided by religion but United by one Identity which is indian. We bleed for the freedom of Indians who belongs to every community and religion. The Brotherhood of Indians can't be divided on the basis of religion and we must ensure it will never. Jai Hind

Latest News

NEP 2020: Revamping higher education and challenges ahead

Hope the government will implement NEP successfully in the higher education system and achieve all its goals in the predicted time. Thus, India will restore its role as a Vishwaguru.

Domestic violence: A grave concern

Domestic violence occurs when one person tries to dominate and control another person in a family-like or domestic relationship. Domestic violence involves...

Justin Trudeau’s unwarranted support to Farmers protests, was made on behest of Khalistani secessionists?

One has to wonder why Canadian PM has to make these unwarranted statements and the underlying aspect is, his coalition government is hanging with the support of the New Democratic Party which is a socialist far left political party and its leader is none other than Khalistani supporter Jagmeet Singh Dhaliwal.

BJP and the need for the saffron party to win GHMC

many, are making fun of this, that just to fight Owaisi brothers and the KCR, BJP had to put their full force in this election, but how many of us have realized the depth of this move by BJP?

Overview of voting trends of Muslims in Bihar election 2020

by observing the overall data, one can conclude that non-Muslim votes are divided into Muslim and non-Muslim candidates while Muslim votes are only divided among Muslim candidates.

Are the phrases “Brahmin left and Brahmin bailout”, a rhetoric of anti-semitism on Brahmin community?

The term Brahmin Left is a new phrase being used by Progressive left to showcase Brahmin community of India. It is not new that Brahmins community is often dragged in western media to malign them in a derogatory way.

Recently Popular

गुप्त काल को स्वर्ण युग क्यों कहा जाता है

एक सफल शासन की नींव समुद्रगप्त ने अपने शासनकाल में ही रख दी थी इसीलिए गुप्त सम्राटों का शासन अत्यधिक सफल रहा। साम्राज्य की दृढ़ता शांति और नागरिकों की उन्नति इसके प्रमाण थे।

सामाजिक भेदभाव: कारण और निवारण

भारत में व्याप्त सामाजिक असामानता केवल एक वर्ग विशेष के साथ जिसे कि दलित कहा जाता है के साथ ही व्यापक रूप से प्रभावी है परंतु आर्थिक असमानता को केवल दलितों में ही व्याप्त नहीं माना जा सकता।

Did this abusive journalist do a ‘fake interview’ while with Hindustan Times?

According to allegations, Swati Chaturvedi published a fake interview with George Fernandes.

The reality of Akbar that our history textbooks don’t teach!

Akbar had over 5,000 wives in his harems, and was regularly asked by his Sunni court officials to limit the number of his wives to 4, due to it being prescribed by the Quran. Miffed with the regular criticism of him violating the Quran, he founded the religion Din-e-illahi

The story of Lord Jagannath and Krishna’s heart

But do we really know the significance of this temple and the story behind the incomplete idols of Lord Jagannath, Lord Balabhadra and Maa Shubhadra?