Sunday, September 20, 2020
Home Opinions Is it possible that government exempts income tax up to Rs 5 Lakh per...

Is it possible that government exempts income tax up to Rs 5 Lakh per annum?

Also Read

A Risk analyst with keen interest in Politics, Finance and Energy.

Last week Income tax department has released the data of Income Tax Return Statistics for Assessment Year 2015-16 which is effectively for Financial Year 2014-15 i.e the first year of Modi govt. This data gives a lot of insight about the direct tax collections in India like which state contributes the highest, how many people paid tax, what is average tax paid by corporate etc etc.

This information has inspired me to write my 2nd article on direct tax (first one being here).

On 10th July 2014 when Mr. Arun Jaitley presented the first budget of Narendra Modi government he raised the personal income tax exemption limit by 25% that is, from Rs. 2 lakh to Rs. 2.5 lakh while he increased the investment limit under section 80C of the Income-tax Act by 50% from Rs. 1 lakh to Rs. 1.5 lakh. At that point of time this was taken as a return gift from Mr Modi on his resounding victory.

These were generous increase by any standard but larger question remains unanswered, WHY central government has not considered simplification of direct tax at that point of time. In 2017 Mr. Jaitley has appointed a committee to simplify the 56 years old direct tax laws to widen the tax base, ease of doing business & improving compliance.

If you ask any economist which tax is more regressive: Direct or Indirect, 99% chances are that they will say Indirect as this tax is same for all strata of society i.e they pay same rate irrespective of their income. Egs: The GST (an indirect tax) on soap could be 5%, the soap which is bought by the poorest as well as the richest. On the other hand direct taxes are progressive as they are higher for higher income i.e. 30% tax slab for income above Rs 10 lacs

But if you will ask common people in India they will say opposite. Everyone wants to pay less direct tax but more or less ok with paying indirect (sometimes hidden) tax as long as all others are paying. This underlying attitude is the reason for abysmally small number of direct tax payers in India. From a population of 1.3 Billion, only 40 million (4 Cr) paid  Individual tax in 2014. We all know quite a large  population of India is either below poverty line/below exemption limit or falls under exemption income like Agriculture but this still doesn’t justify Income tax filing by less than 5%.


From the 2014-15 data for Income Tax Returns of Individuals we can actually deduce that if Mr Jaitley had taken the decision of simplifying the personal income tax by increasing the personal income tax exemption limit while removing the exemptions, it would have been a great decision.

As per the IT data released, sum of Income tax payable was 1,88,031 Cr. Now let us consider 3 scenarios replicating the tax rates:

Scenario 1: 2.5 Lakh exemption limit & 1.5 lakh 80 C investment limit: In this scenario collection would have been 1,94,927 Cr. But since we have other than 80 C exemptions as well the actual tax payable, actual tax payable is little less i.e 1,88,031 Cr.


Scenario 2: 4.5 Lakh as exemption limit with 0 investment limit: Total tax payable would have been 1,87,735 Cr only 296 Cr less than what govt achieved during 2014-15.

Scenario 3: 5 Lakh as exemption limit with 0 investment limit: Total tax payable would have been 1,80,268 Cr only which means 7762 Cr hit on Govt finances.

                                       Individual- Range of Tax Payable (AY 2015-16)

Range No. of Returns Sum of Gross (cr) Average Gross (lakh) Scenario 1 (2.5L+1.5 L) Scenario 2

(4.5 L+0L)

Scenario 3 (5L+0L)
< 0              1,08,062
>0 and <=1,50,000           21,60,364                      18,289                                   0.85                   –                 –                 –
>150,000 and <= 2,00,000           15,61,078                      27,860                                   1.78                   –                 –                 –
>2,00,000 and <=2,50,000           43,69,446                   1,00,866                                   2.31                   –                 –                 –
>2,50,000 and <= 3,50,000        1,33,61,610                   3,88,735                                   2.91                   –                 –                 –
>3,50,000 and <= 4,00,000           33,11,801                   1,23,751                                   3.74                   –                 –                 –
>4,00,000 and <= 4,50,000           27,63,811                   1,16,960                                   4.23               641                 –                 –
>4,50,000 and <= 5,00,000           20,22,386                      95,917                                   4.74            1,502              491                 –
>5,00,000 and <= 5,50,000           16,87,835                      88,421                                   5.24            2,494          1,650              806
>5,50,000 and <= 9,50,000           61,40,397                   4,28,653                                   6.98         30,467        27,397        24,327
>9,50,000 and <= 10,00,000              3,02,399                      29,467                                   9.74            3,172          3,021          1,435
>10,00,000 and <=15,00,000           15,15,662                   1,82,066                                 12.01         25,822        25,064        24,307
>15,00,000 and <= 20,00,000              5,93,658                   1,01,939                                 17.17         19,302        19,005        18,709
>20,00,000 and <= 25,00,000              2,83,331                      62,977                                 22.23         13,510        13,368        13,226
>25,00,000 and <= 50,00,000              3,81,228                   1,27,824                                 33.53         31,104        30,913        30,723
>50,00,000 and <= 1 cr              1,16,901                      79,992                                 68.43         21,776        21,718        21,660
>1 cr and <=5 cr                 55,331                   1,00,179                              181.05         29,002        28,975        28,947
>5cr and <=10cr                    3,020                      20,323                              672.95            6,040          6,038          6,037
>10cr and <=25cr                    1,156                      16,862                           1,458.65            5,037          5,036          5,035
>25cr and <=50cr                       233                         8,114                           3,482.40            2,430          2,430          2,430
>50cr and <=100cr                          58                         3,873                           6,677.59            1,161          1,161          1,161
>100cr and <=500cr                          31                         4,175                        13,467.74            1,252          1,252          1,252
>500cr                            1                            721                        72,100.00               216              216              216
Total        4,07,39,799                21,27,964      1,94,927    1,87,735    1,80,268

Obviously changing the tax laws can have both positive as well as negative consequences.

The positive impact is mainly convenience to general public. Tax laws are difficult to understand be it Direct or Indirect. People don’t understand why they need to invest first in PPF, NPS, ELSS, PF, LIC to save tax and why all of these have different lock-in periods. Moreover people have a genuine complaint that they should survive first or save? If someone is earning Rs 30000 per month in tier 2 cities then probably average saving would be 5000/month. But to save tax he needs to invest all his money for some years and survive hard times to see that invested money.

With increasing limit obviously tax base which is already 1.7% will reduce further. With a flat Rs 5 lakh exemption limit we would have only 1.1 Cr Individual tax payers in India. This goes against the general rule of having a bigger tax base. Also the starting tax rate would be 20% instead of 10% (5% now) which could further increased tax evasion cases.

The challenge still lies to find the equilibrium between the positive and negative scenarios which I will explore in my next article.

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

A Risk analyst with keen interest in Politics, Finance and Energy.

Latest News

“UPSC Jihad”: A tale of ignominious judicial capriciousness

The Indian judiciary appears to lose all semblance of nuance so soon as the word, “minority” appears. This is yet another problem in the Hollow Republic of India — and I use that term after prodigious consideration.

Bappa Rawal – The legend untold

Bappa Rawal in a sense had broken the myth that Indian Kings could not unite against foreign invaders to protect the mother land. The fake narrative to divide and derecognize them has been in history books for too long

वो यात्रा जो सफलता से अधिक संघर्ष बयाँ करती है

आज भारत विश्व में अपनी नई पहचान के साथ आगे बढ़ रहा है। वो भारत जो कल तक गाँधी का भारत था जिसकी पहचान उसकी सहनशीलता थी, आज मोदी का भारत है जो खुद पहल करता नहीं, किसी को छेड़ता नहीं लेकिन अगर कोई उसे छेड़े तो छोड़ता भी नहीं।

One nation, one market 2020: Will the dream come true?

New policies of Modi govt for farmers is for their betterment. However, as always, the opposition just does not want the farmers to be better.

Lessons from Sweden

What happened after seventy years, which is making Europe moving for right wing and Nationalism again? Why is a country like Sweden today feeling the heat? What changed in past decade that made liberal society to change?

Mirror of self-discovery in pandemic

This year has been really horrific. Obnoxious amount of sadness, sickness and death. Nature forced us to confront ourselves in a lot many ways. But hope prevails. The waves of faith keep crashing the beach.

Recently Popular

Mughals are NOT Indians

In this article we analyse whether Mughals were Indians or invaders who stayed because of the vast wealth and resources and also the power it gave them in the Islamic world.

5 Cases where True Indology exposed Audrey Truschke

Her claims have been busted, but she continues to peddle her agenda

Daredevil of Indian Army: Para SF Major Mohit Sharma’s who became Iftikaar Bhatt to kill terrorists

Such brave souls of Bharat Mata who knows every minute of their life may become the last minute.

Digital service delivery will bolster an Atmanirbhar Bharat

A clear vision of the Digital India program has stimulated the efficiency of digital service delivery by ensuring development at the grassroots level via the formulation of 796 digital villages and more than 3.6 lakh functional common services centers offering digital access points for the delivery of essential public utility services

पोषण अभियान: सही पोषण – देश रोशन

भारत सरकार द्वारा कुपोषण को दूर करने के लिए जीवनचक्र एप्रोच अपनाकर चरणबद्ध ढंग से पोषण अभियान चलाया जा रहा है, भारत...