Monday, November 30, 2020
Home Opinions Reservations, Politics and Propaganda

Reservations, Politics and Propaganda

Also Read

If the decision in Keshavananda Bharati helped to preserve the unity and integrity of India, the decision of the SC in Indra Sawhney v. UOI popularly called the Mandal case- polarised Indian society by upholding reservations that are almost exclusively based on caste. In other way this judgment legitimized Cased-Based Reservations in India.

After this art. 15 (4) was added in the constitution through the constitutional amendment which authorized the State to make special provisions for the advancment of ‘socially and educationally backward classes’ and court also held that caste could not be the sole reason for determining backward classes. While the exact percentage may vary, it could not cross the 50% limit, said SC.

Furthermore, all the reports starting with Kaka Kalelkar Commission to Mandal Commission were flawed. They were not well researched at all as Indira Gandhi never implemented this report, although it was tabled in Parliament first in 1982. She fully knew its defects and disastrous long term consequences of pure caste-based reservation. Even Rajiv Gandhi too never implemented it. It was VP Singh, to save his personal political fortune, resurrected the report and, by announcing a 27% reservation for OBCs, altered the political landscape of the country forever.

Palkhivala famously once wrote after the Indra Sawhney judgment: ‘I am sure V.P. Singh was sincere when he said that after the SC judgment in the Mandal case he could die in peace. But his policy has ensured that the nation will not live in peace…’

*Present Scenario*
Firstly, this is a very bold step by Modi and most importantly he has reflected his political will by proposing this bill. This Bill will easily pass the judicial scrutiny and 50% reservation cap since this is an economic based reservation which is done through a constitutional amendment by adding clause 6 in art. 15 and 16. So Indra Sawhney judgment is irrelevant in this case. Also this need not to be ratified by the state assemblies unlike other constitutional amendments because it is mentioned in the constitution that amendment of part 3 need not to be ratified by the states.

But I feel this is unconstitutional and undemocratic move the reason being simply that proposal of bill when only 5 odd months are left for the General Elections and there is a convention that any big announcements must not be done in the last session of Parliament when the LS elections are about to occur and therefore it is the rule that govt. shall bring Interim Budget and not the Union Budget in the last year of its tenure. (It is a convention not obligation that govt. brings Interim Budged and not the full fledge budget in its last year so that they may not polarize the people.) This is the jurisprudence behind this convention so that the govt. do not polarise the people by virtue of its office in Parliament and the same applies here but that convention has been broken by this govt. after this act.

Furthermore, the intention of the govt. can’t be questioned as many of us are saying that this is mere jumla for taking votes because had their intention been to just use this bill as “jumla”, they could have added this into the 9th schedule which the court would have overruled on the basis of Basic Structure Doctrine or could have given the notification as Congress did in 2014 with Jats reservation but they didn’t do this rather they brought a costitutional amendment and offered a proposal which opp. could not deny which shows their seriousness about the issue.

Now, the political propaganda behind this is to regain those NOTA votes due to which they lost in MP as upper castes were not happy with BJP after that SC/ST atrocities row.

Lastly, as some people are saying that since there are no jobs then what will this reservation do, 10% of 0 still remains 0 is another issue.

  Support Us  

OpIndia is not rich like the mainstream media. Even a small contribution by you will help us keep running. Consider making a voluntary payment.

Trending now

Latest News

गुपकार गैंग द्वारा रोशनी एक्ट की आड़ में किया गया 25000 करोड़ रुपए का घोटाला!

व्यवस्था का लाभ उठाकर 2001 से 2007 के बीच गुपकार गैंग वालों ने मिलकर जम्मू-कश्मीर को जहाँ से मौका मिला वहाँ से लूटा, खसोटा, बेचा व नीलाम किया और बेचारी जनता मायूसी के अंधकार में मूकदर्शक बनी देखती रही।

Death of the farmer vote bank

While in the case of a farmer the reform delivered double benefit but the political class faces double whammy, that of losing its captive vote bank that was dependent on its sops and secondly losing the massive income they earned as middlemen between the farmer and the consumer. Either the farmer is misinformed or wrongly instigated, otherwise it is impossible to conceive that any farmer should be actually unhappy or opposed for being given more choices, as to whom to sell their produce.

Teachers assign essays with a 280 character limit

This a satire news article, which 'reports' that the government has added 280 character essays to the educational curriculum in an attempt to train students to use Twitter in the future. Note: I have chosen an image of a school from your media library and added the twitter logo on top of it.

हिन्दू विरोधी वैचारिक प्रपंच, शब्दों का भ्रम (भाग-१)

धर्म शब्द को जिस प्रकार अनुचित अनर्थकारी व्याख्या के साथ प्रचलित किया गया है। इससे अधिक विनाशकारी आघात हिन्दू समाज को संभवतः ही किसी और शब्द से हुआ हो।

Ind vs Aus 1st ODI में ऑस्ट्रेलिया का भारत के खिलाफ नया वनडे रिकॉर्ड

आज का दिन भारतीय टीम के फैन्स के लिए निराशा भरा रहा जिसमे आज भारत और ऑस्ट्रेलिया के बीच मे खेली जा रही 3 वनडे मैचों की सीरीज के पहले मैच में ऑस्ट्रेलिया ने भारत को 66 रन से हरा दिया है और अब इस 3 एकदिवसीय मैच की सीरीज में 1-0 की लीड बना ली है।

26/11 : संघ और हिंदूओं को बदनाम करने के लिए कांग्रेस का सबसे घटिया प्रयास

Hinduism is a complex, inclusive, liberal, tolerant, open and multi-faceted socio-spiritual system of India called “Dharma”. Due to its innumerable divergences, Hinduism has no concept of ‘Apostasy’.

Recently Popular

गुप्त काल को स्वर्ण युग क्यों कहा जाता है

एक सफल शासन की नींव समुद्रगप्त ने अपने शासनकाल में ही रख दी थी इसीलिए गुप्त सम्राटों का शासन अत्यधिक सफल रहा। साम्राज्य की दृढ़ता शांति और नागरिकों की उन्नति इसके प्रमाण थे।

How media and vested interest group destroyed our Army’s perfectly working, very effective Covert Intel Unit: Part-1

While this special unit's men were doing what they do best, diligently working, putting their own life at risks for the country, but all was not calm on the Delhi Front.

सामाजिक भेदभाव: कारण और निवारण

भारत में व्याप्त सामाजिक असामानता केवल एक वर्ग विशेष के साथ जिसे कि दलित कहा जाता है के साथ ही व्यापक रूप से प्रभावी है परंतु आर्थिक असमानता को केवल दलितों में ही व्याप्त नहीं माना जा सकता।

The story of Lord Jagannath and Krishna’s heart

But do we really know the significance of this temple and the story behind the incomplete idols of Lord Jagannath, Lord Balabhadra and Maa Shubhadra?

How media and vested interest group destroyed our Army’s perfectly working, very effective Covert Intel Unit: Part-2

media instead of being the fourth pillar of democracy has been used by establishment and vested interest groups to peddle their agenda and try to change public perception.